Claude Prompt: Removal Defense Case-Theory Memo From the NTA and File
Turns the Notice to Appear, the court record and the client file into an internal case-theory memo: hearing dates first, each factual allegation and charge tested against the records, the relief options the attorney is weighing framed with the facts that bear on them, and the evidence to gather.
The Prompt
Variables (7)
| Variable | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| {{client_name}} | Client Name | Teodoro Ilunga Massamba |
| {{current_date}} | Today's Date | 2026-11-18 |
| {{nta_text}} | Notice to Appear Text | Allegation 3: You entered the United States at or near Hidalgo, Texas, on or about June 5, 2019. |
| {{court_record}} | Court Record and Hearing Notices | Notice of hearing: master calendar hearing, January 12, 2027, 8:30 a.m. |
| {{client_file}} | Client Account and Documents | Passport admission stamp, JFK, 2019-06-05, class B-2. |
| {{relief_considered}} | Relief the Attorney Is Considering | Cancellation of removal for non-permanent residents; voluntary departure as a fallback. |
| {{authority_text}} | Statute, Regulation, Policy or Decision Text | NONE |
Expected Output
An <analysis> block, then the memo: hearing dates and detention facts first; an allegations table testing each NTA allegation against the records; each charge quoted with an authority marker; conflicts; arithmetic differences on stated durations; a chronology; the facts bearing for and against each relief the attorney names, with authority markers for the requirements; asserted authorities labeled unverified; declined statements and requests; evidence, witnesses and client questions; missing information; and a closing Verification list.
Usage Notes
Use when you take on a removal case or before the first master calendar hearing. Paste the Notice to Appear word for word, every hearing notice, the client's documents and account, and name the relief you are weighing. Check every hearing date against the court notice itself. Failure mode to watch: a residence or presence period, a bar or the elements of a form of relief written from memory, or a recommendation to concede an allegation; the prompt forbids each. Not legal advice. The attorney remains responsible for verifying every fact, figure and authority before use.
Double-check before use
- Check how each arrest or incident is described against the record. In testing, an arrest was given a label the record did not use.
These are the places where this prompt was seen to slip when tested on sample cases with a small AI model.
Legal Sources Referenced
- 8 U.S.C. § 1229a(c)(4)(A) (an applicant for relief or protection from removal has the burden of proof to establish eligibility and that discretion should be exercised favorably)
Originally featured in: Prompt Engineering for Lawyers: The Complete 2026 Guide
Related Prompts
Claude Prompt: O-1A Extraordinary Ability Evidence Mapping
Maps a candidate's CV and exhibits to each O-1A criterion you paste, rates how far each is documented on the face of the evidence, lists gaps and exhibits to gather, and drafts a criteria outline for the petition letter.
Claude Prompt: Immigration Intake and Issue-Spotting Memo
Turns first-consultation notes and the documents the client brought into an internal memo: urgent dates first, a status chronology, documented versus told facts, conflicts, the issues to research and the questions to ask. It decides no eligibility and states no law, fee or processing time.
Claude Prompt: Response to a USCIS Notice of Intent to Deny
Drafts the response to a USCIS notice of intent to deny: each ground quoted, the derogatory information it relies on, the rebuttal evidence tested against its own dates, and a ground-by-ground response that argues only from pasted authority, with attorney-only notes kept apart.
Claude Prompt: Qualifying Relative Hardship Declaration for a Waiver
Drafts the first-person declaration of the qualifying relative for a waiver application: the relative's own account of the consequences they describe, medical and financial facts only as the records state them, budgets recomputed, and no hardship standard or factor list from memory.
* These prompts are drafting and analysis aids for licensed attorneys. They are not legal advice and do not replace professional judgment. AI output can contain errors, including invented citations and incorrect deadlines: verify every fact, figure, authority and deadline against primary sources before relying on it. Rules vary by jurisdiction, and you remain responsible for the final work product.